Social Studies
Objective: I can choose a real community issue for my project and explain who it affects.
Standards: D4.6.3-5, D2.Civ.10.3-5, D4.8.3-5, D1.1.3-5, D1.2.3-5
Builds on: Needs Day 1 (the six steps) and Week 8 Day 1 (compelling questions). One-minute check: "What is a compelling question?" (A big question worth investigating that people may answer in different ways.)
- issue – a problem that affects many people and that people may see in different ways
Materials: Civic Action Project planner, Step 2 (or a notebook page titled Step 2), Noticing list and Step 1 ideas from Day 1, 1 sheet of paper (issue-choosing chart), 3 small paper slips (for a family vote if two ideas tie), Notebook, Pencil
- Warm-Up · 5 min
Spaced review from Week 7. Ask: "What is a point of view?" (How one person or group sees and feels about something.) Then ask the big question: "Which problem on your noticing list bothers you the most, and why?"
- Mini-Lesson · 10–15 min
Say: "An issue is a problem that affects many people. A good project issue passes five tests." "Is it real? We saw it ourselves." "Is it local? It is in our town, school or neighborhood." "Is it kid-sized? We can do something in two weeks with an adult." "Does it help others?" "Is it safe?" Say: "Idea 1: end all pollution. It is not local and not kid-sized. It scores 3 out of 5." Say: "Idea 2: litter by the Oak Street bench. It passes all five tests." Say: "People can see one issue differently. A new dog park may please dog owners. Neighbors may worry about barking. Their views come from what they care about. A good citizen listens to both." Say: "Next, turn the issue into a compelling question, such as 'How can we keep our playground clean?' People may answer it in different ways." Ask: "Who else would care about the answer, and why?" (Sample: families who play there.) Ask: "Which tests does 'stop all littering everywhere' fail?" (Local and kid-sized.) Ask: "Why might the neighbors and the dog owners disagree?" (They care about different things: quiet, or a place for dogs to run.) If stuck, say: "Could we work on it this week, near home, with a grown-up?"
- Activity / Source Work · 15–20 min
Choose an issue. 1) On the sheet of paper, draw a chart with seven columns: Idea | Real | Local | Kid-sized | Helps others | Safe | Score. 2) Your child writes the top three ideas from Step 1 in the first column. 3) For each idea, mark one point for every test it passes. Write the score out of 5. 4) Choose the idea with the highest score. If two tie, hold a family vote. Each person gives one reason first, then votes on a paper slip. 5) Your child names two groups the issue affects. 6) Your child names one person or group who might see it differently and tells what they care about. Sample: "The park workers may say they have too few helpers." 7) Ask for evidence: "Show me on the chart why this idea won." Look for an issue that scores 5, such as playground litter or a food bank that needs supplies. If no idea scores 5, shrink one together until it does.
- Notebook Entry · 10 min
On Step 2, your child writes an issue statement. "In our ___, ___ is a problem because ___. It affects ___." Below it, write the compelling question: "How can we ___?" Sample: "In our park, litter by the bench is a problem because it blows into the playground. It affects kids and families."
- Exit Ticket · 5 min
Read the questions aloud. Your child answers aloud, then writes question 1. Praise listening to another point of view.
Watch for: Picking a problem that is too large, such as "world hunger" or "pollution."
Try: Shrink it together. Ask: "Where can we help with that near us? This week?" Stop when it is local and doable.
- Which issue is kid-sized: hunger around the world, or an empty shelf at the town food bank? Tell why.
- Name two groups of people your issue affects.
- Name someone who might see your issue differently. What might that person care about?
Show answers
- The empty shelf. It is local, and a child can help in a short time with an adult.
- Answers vary. Look for: two real groups, such as children who use the park and families who walk there.
- Answers vary. Look for: a real person or group and something they value, such as cost, quiet or safety.
Support: Offer three ready issues to score: park litter, a book drive, or thank-you notes for community workers. Your child picks one.
Extend: With an adult, your child interviews one person who might see the issue differently. Write what that person cares about.
Homework: Your child reads the issue statement to a family member and asks who else it affects. Look for one new group added to the notebook.
Practice page · Week 33, Day 2
Social Studies
I can choose a real community issue and tell who it affects.
Look: the five tests
- Is it real and local? Did we see it in our town?
- Is it kid-sized? Can we help in two weeks with an adult?
- Does it help others, and is it safe?
Choose an Issue: give each idea 1 point for every test it passes.
| Idea | Real | Local | Kid-sized | Helps | Safe | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
- 1.
My top idea and its score:
- 2.
Fix the potholes on the highway yourself. Which tests does it fail?
- 3.
Two groups my issue affects:
People can see an issue in different ways.
- 4.
A town plans a new skate park. Who might be glad?
- 5.
Who might worry, and why?
- 6.
Write your issue: In our ____, ____ is a problem because ____. My compelling question: How can we ____?
Challenge: Why should a good citizen listen to people who see an issue differently?