Social Studies
Objective: I can compare Ellis Island and Angel Island, two places where many immigrants arrived.
Standards: D2.His.2.3-5, D2.His.14.3-5, D2.His.16.3-5, D3.4.3-5, D2.His.12.3-5, D2.His.11.3-5
Builds on: Needs Day 1 (what immigration means) and Week 10 (the two oceans). One-minute check: "Which ocean lies between China and the U.S.?" (The Pacific.)
- immigration station – a place where officials checked newcomers' papers and health before they could enter
- exclusion – keeping someone out
Materials: U.S. map, Notebook, Pencil
- Warm-Up · 5 min
Spaced review from Week 13. Ask: "The first railroad across the country was finished in 1869. Workers from which two countries did much of the hard work?" (China and Ireland.) Then ask: "You arrive by ship 100 years ago. What might officials ask you?"
- Mini-Lesson · 10–15 min
Say: "Long ago, most immigrants came by ship. They landed at immigration stations, where officials checked papers and health." Point to New York Harbor on the map. Say: "Ellis Island was the main East Coast station from 1892 to 1954. About 12 million people passed through. Most came from Europe. Many saw the Statue of Liberty as they sailed in. Most were let in within a few hours." Point to San Francisco Bay. Say: "Angel Island was the main West Coast station from 1910 to 1940. Many people there came from China, Japan and other parts of Asia." Say: "In 1882 a law called the Chinese Exclusion Act kept most people from China out. It treated people unfairly because of where they came from. Officers at Angel Island questioned Chinese immigrants for weeks or months." Ask: "Which station was on the West Coast?" (Angel Island.) "Why did many Chinese immigrants wait so long?" (The 1882 law. Officers questioned them for weeks or months.) If stuck, say: "Point to the island. Which ocean is beside it?"
- Activity / Source Work · 15–20 min
Two sources. 1) Read both aloud. Source A describes a real photograph. "The photo was taken at Ellis Island in the early 1900s. Hundreds of people wait in a huge hall, in rows between metal rails. They hold bundles and babies. Inspectors stand at tall desks at the far end. A large American flag hangs above." Source B describes real poems. "More than 200 poems are carved into the wooden walls of the men's sleeping room at Angel Island. They are written in Chinese. Most are not signed. Many tell of sadness and anger at being locked in. Some give advice to travelers who come later." 2) Ask: "What do you notice? What do you wonder?" Your child writes two wonder questions. One must connect both sources. (Sample: "Why did people at Angel Island have time to carve poems?") 3) Ask about Source B: "Who made them?" (People held there.) "Who was meant to read them? What is your clue?" (Other Chinese travelers. The poems are in Chinese and give advice.) "Why were they made?" (To share feelings and help others.) 4) Your child fills a chart in the notebook: Place | Coast | Years open | Where many came from | Usual wait. Expect: Ellis Island, East, 1892 to 1954, Europe, a few hours. Angel Island, West, 1910 to 1940, Asia, weeks or months for many.
- Notebook Entry · 10 min
Your child writes: "Ellis Island and Angel Island were alike because ___. They were different because ___." Then a claim: "Waiting was usually longer at ___ Island. My evidence is ___." Sample: "Waiting was usually longer at Angel Island. My evidence is that people had time to carve poems."
- Exit Ticket · 5 min
Read each exit question aloud. Your child may use the chart. Praise answers that point to a source.
Watch for: Thinking the long waits at Angel Island happened only because the station was slow or crowded.
Try: Reread the sentence about the 1882 law. Ask: "Who did the law keep out?"
- You sail from Japan in 1912. At which station would you most likely arrive? Tell why.
- Which law made the wait at Angel Island so long for many Chinese immigrants? What did it do?
- A poem on the wall says the writer misses home. Who do you think the writer wanted to read it? Give a clue.
Show answers
- Angel Island. It was the West Coast station, across the Pacific from Asia.
- The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. It kept most people from China out of the U.S.
- Answers vary. Look for: other people held there or later travelers; the poem is in Chinese and on the wall where they slept.
Support: Fill in the Coast and Years open columns together. Your child finishes the rest.
Extend: Your child writes two sentences on how a poem writer may have felt, using Source B.
Homework: Your child tells a family member one way the islands were alike and one difference. Look for: both checked newcomers; coasts or waits differed.
Practice page · Week 16, Day 2
Social Studies
I can compare Ellis Island and Angel Island, two places where many immigrants arrived.
Fill in the chart. Then answer the questions.
| Place | Coast | Years open | Many people came from | Waiting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
- 1.
Which island was on the East Coast?
- 2.
Which island was in San Francisco Bay?
- 3.
Where did most people who came through Ellis Island come from?
- 4.
Where did many people who came through Angel Island come from?
- 5.
At which island did people usually wait much longer? Give one piece of evidence.
Answer in a sentence.
- 6.
Write one way the two islands were alike.
Challenge: Some people waiting at Angel Island carved poems into the walls. Why do you think they did that?
Materials: U.S. map